Key takeaways
-
This study was led by researchers from the Gastrointestinal Eosinophilic Diseases Program.
-
Eosinophilic esophagitis (EoE) is more likely to be diagnosed in children that are white, non-Hispanic, English-speaking and from socioeconomic-advantaged neighborhoods.
-
These differences are likely due to structural factors and health inequities affecting historically marginalized communities.
Background: studying disparities in patients with eosinophilic esophagitis (EoE)
Race, ethnicity and socioeconomic status are known to affect rates of hospital admission, readmission and mortality. There is also disparity in disease prevalence and health outcomes based on race, socioeconomic status and urbanization for several atopic diseases, including asthma.
Eosinophilic esophagitis (EoE) is a rare atopic disease driven by food allergies that is increasing in incidence and prevalence.
- Thought to primarily impact White, non-Hispanic patients
- A recent study found children in high poverty or rural areas are less likely to be diagnosed with EoE
This study was led by researchers from the Gastrointestinal Eosinophilic Diseases Program within the Digestive Health Institute at Children’s Hospital Colorado. Researchers included Pooja Mehta, MD, Zhaoxing Pan, PhD, Calies Menard-Katcher, MD, and Glenn Furuta, MD.
There were two key objectives:
- Identify patient and neighborhood characteristics of children with EoE diagnosis in a large tertiary care center with broad catchment area.
- Determine if there are any associations between a patient’s demographics or neighborhood advantage/disadvantage and depth of evaluation or treatment choices.
Methods: a retrospective cohort study of children with EoE
Data from electronic health records for children up to 18 years old seen at Children’s Colorado were included in this retrospective cohort study if they met the following criteria:
- Resided in Colorado
- Diagnosed with EoE (based on ICD-9 or ICD-10 codes)
- Seen in hospital’s general gastroenterology clinic or multidisciplinary eosinophilic esophagitis clinic between Jan. 1, 2009, and Dec. 31, 2020
Study population demographics were compared to demographics of patients seen at Children’s Colorado during the same period.
- Rural-Urban Commuting Area (RUCA) taxonomy codes used to classify patients as living in rural or urban areas
- Area Deprivation Index (ADI) scores calculated using home addresses (1 to 100 percentiles (nationally) and 1 to 10 deciles (state); higher scores indicate more neighborhood disadvantage)
There were 2,117 children included in the study.
Results: factors impacting presentation, management of EoE
Sample characteristics of the study population compared patients seen at Children’s Hospital Colorado during the same time:
Characteristics |
Study population (Patients with EoE) |
Hospital population |
Race (most common) |
|
|
Black/African American |
4.6% |
5% |
Mixed race |
7.4% |
4% |
Other |
5.3% |
13% |
White |
77.6% |
53% |
Not reported/missing values |
3.3% |
22% |
Ethnicity |
|
|
Hispanic |
12.2% |
22% |
Not Hispanic |
85.6% |
54% |
Not reported/missing values |
4.2% |
24% |
Primary spoken language (guardian) |
|
|
English |
96.5% |
80% |
Spanish |
2.4% |
13% |
Other |
1.1% |
7% |
Urbanization |
|
|
Urban |
92.8% |
unknown |
Rural |
7.2% |
unknown |
Of note:
- Fewer children from rural areas in study population than in Colorado general population (2020 census data)
- Majority of children from more advantaged neighborhoods
- 19th percentile median national ADI score
- 4th decile state score
- ADI scores indicate higher social economic status of study population than general population of U.S. and Colorado
Impact of neighborhood advantage/disadvantage
Patients with higher state ADI/greater neighborhood disadvantage:
- Slight correlation with body mass index z-score at diagnosis
- Less likely to have radiographic evaluation of their disease
- More likely to have esophageal dilation at younger age
- Less frequently seen at multidisciplinary clinic
ADI was not associated with:
- Age of diagnosis
- Seeing a feeding therapist or dietitian
- Age of seeing feeding therapist or dietitian
- Needing esophageal dilation or esophageal foreign body removal
Impact of race, ethnicity, and urbanization
Compared to White children, Black children were younger at:
- EoE diagnosis
- First feeding therapy visit
- First dietitian visit
- First dilation
After multivariate analysis, race was not significantly associated with age of seeing feeding therapist, dietitian or first dilation.
Compared to White children, Hispanic children had:
- Slightly higher body mass index z-score at diagnosis
- No other differences
Language was not significantly associated with any finding.
Compared to children from urban areas, children from rural areas were:
- Less likely to be seen by feeding therapy
- When seen, were younger
Univariate regression analysis found factors that lowered the likelihood of being seen in a multidisciplinary EoE clinic (per unit increase in state ADI decile):
- Higher ADI
- Black or non-white children
- Hispanic children
After multivariate analysis, ADI was the only significant factor associated with decreased likelihood of being seen in a multidisciplinary EoE clinic.
Discussion and conclusion: health disparities include race, social determinants of health
Findings from this study showed differences in disease presentation and management of EoE varied by race and social determinants of health, though it is unknown why.
Study authors observed children who were Black, from rural areas and disadvantaged areas appeared to experience greater disease severity based on age of dilation and age of seeing dietitians/feeding therapists. They noted a growing body of evidence supporting race is not a reliable substitute for genetic difference.
Study authors hypothesized:
- Differences documented in the study are not genetic but may be result of structural factors and health inequities
- Patients with EoE often subtly adapt to their disease instead of seeking medical care
- Possible only most severe patients referred to specialty care
- Structural factors of more severe atopic diseases in marginalized communities may exist for EoE
They also identified potentially important areas of intervention to address disparities in the EoE population:
- Hospital systems need to develop structures and process to support equity and improve access to specialists, including pediatric gastroenterologists, allergists, dietitians, feeding therapists
Policy changes need to be made to improve access to care and equitable opportunities - feeding therapists, dietitians knowledgeable in EoE limited in rural areas and are not often covered by insurance.
Featured researchers
Glenn Furuta, MD
Director
Digestive Health Institute
Children's Hospital Colorado
Professor
Pediatrics-Gastroenterology, Hepatology and Nutrition
University of Colorado School of Medicine
Pooja Mehta, MD
Pediatric gastroenterologist
Digestive Health Institute
Children's Hospital Colorado
Assistant professor
Pediatrics-Gastroenterology, Hepatology and Nutrition
University of Colorado School of Medicine
Calies Menard-Katcher, MD
Pediatric gastroenterologist
Digestive Health Institute
Children's Hospital Colorado
Associate professor
Pediatrics-Gastroenterology, Hepatology and Nutrition
University of Colorado School of Medicine